Are the rationale and regulatory system for protecting human subjects of biomedical and behavioral research obsolete and unworkable, or ethically important but inconvenient and inadequately enforced?
نویسنده
چکیده
Many critics of U.S. regulation to protect human subjects of biomedical and behavioral research deem the system inherently unworkable and variously inadequate or unnecessary. Many deem its rationale, the Belmont Report, outdated and philosophically deficient. Some would scrap or revamp the system. These criticisms and prescriptions are challenging factually, legally, and ethically. Similar minimalist, audited self-regulation operates smoothly elsewhere in life science. Events suggest Belmont's continuing validity in its administrative-law role as interpretive touchstone for human subjects protection regulations. U.S. human subjects protection and related regulations are constitutionally grounded and consistent with U.S. obligations under human rights law. Criticisms that the system is inconvenient do not respond to ethical and legal duties--to acknowledge the innate dignity of human subjects of research, to recognize and squarely face ethical issues in human subjects research, to heed applicable domestic and international law, to say no to projects when no is warranted, to foster researcher involvement in the system, to focus on substance rather than form, and to resist automaticity. If the system is to function protectively and reasonably efficiently, then the legitimacy of the pertinent law and Belmont's legal role should be recognized as the primary resource for interpreting the human subjects regulations; the system and proposed changes should be viewed critically for efficacy rather than convenience; and policy and practice should emphasize (a) predictability, stability, and clarity of the regulatory system, and (b) resources and will to comply and enforce.
منابع مشابه
Ethical Aspects of Breast Cancer Treatment
According to a universal consensus and agreement, all diagnostic, curative and rehabilitative medical intervention and biomedical research on patients as human participants, including those related to breast disease and breast cancer, must be performed in a morally acceptable manner. In other words, a medical decision would be “right” if it is ethically justifiable. Similar to diagn...
متن کاملBehavioral Considerations in Developing Web Information Systems: User-centered Design Agenda
The current paper explores designing a web information retrieval system regarding the searching behavior of users in real and everyday life. Designing an information system that is closely linked to human behavior is equally important for providers and the end users. From an Information Science point of view, four approaches in designing information retrieval systems were identified as system-...
متن کاملEthical Aspects of Breast Cancer Treatment
According to a universal consensus and agreement, all diagnostic, curative and rehabilitative medical intervention and biomedical research on patients as human participants, including those related to breast disease and breast cancer, must be performed in a morally acceptable manner. In other words, a medical decision would be “right” if it is ethically justifiable. Similar to diagn...
متن کاملAn Automated MR Image Segmentation System Using Multi-layer Perceptron Neural Network
Background: Brain tissue segmentation for delineation of 3D anatomical structures from magnetic resonance (MR) images can be used for neuro-degenerative disorders, characterizing morphological differences between subjects based on volumetric analysis of gray matter (GM), white matter (WM) and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), but only if the obtained segmentation results are correct. Due to image arti...
متن کاملRevolutionizing Tissue Engineering through Mirroring Cell Niche and Application of Natural Compounds
onsidering the high prevalence of severe organ failures due to the cancer, congenital anomaly, or trauma, and the consequent needs for tissue transplantation, deficiencies in tissues and organs are a huge challenge for regenerative medicine at the moment. More than 40 years have passed since the term ‘tissue engineering’ was created as a new th...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- The Journal of contemporary health law and policy
دوره 20 1 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2003